Jack Daniels Margarita Recipe

Let me tell you about the cocktail that changed my weekends forever – the Jack Daniels Margarita. My husband (a retired bartender) made this for me five years ago, and we’ve shared it every Friday night since.

What I love? You only need three ingredients and one minute to make it taste like a $20 bar drink. No fancy tools, no complicated steps – just whiskey, amaretto, and a sunny orange peel.

I’ll show you exactly how we make it at home, why Jack Daniels works better than regular tequila here, and how to adjust it if you’re out of amaretto.

Trust me, once you try this sweet-and-smoky twist on a classic margarita, you’ll never go back to basic mixes.

Is Jack Daniels Good for Cocktails?

I used to think whiskey was only for old-fashioned drinks – until my husband mixed it into a margarita. Jack Daniels works surprisingly well in cocktails because of its caramel sweetness and hint of vanilla. Unlike sharper bourbons, it doesn’t overpower other ingredients. Here’s why I reach for this bottle:

1. Balanced flavor: The oak-barrel aging gives it a smoothness that plays nice with citrus and sweet liqueurs like amaretto.
2. Widely available: You can find it at any liquor store – no hunting for rare brands.
3. Consistent quality: Every bottle tastes the same, so your cocktails turn out right every time.

Jack Daniels Margarita Ingredients

To make this delicious Jack Daniels Margarita, you’ll need just three simple ingredients:

• Jack Daniels Bourbon (1.5 oz/45 ml): The star. Use the black label No. 7 – the green label Tennessee Honey version makes the drink too sugary.
• Amaretto (1.5 oz/45 ml): This almond liqueur adds dessert-like sweetness. Disaronno is my go-to, but any brand works.
• Ice cubes (5 standard cubes): Crushed ice melts too fast. Big cubes keep the drink cold without watering it down.

For Garnish:

• Orange peel: Not just decoration! The oils in the peel add a fresh citrus aroma.

Substitutions & Variations

No amaretto? Try these instead:

• 1 oz maple syrup + ½ tsp almond extract
• 1.5 oz Southern Comfort (adds peach notes)
• 1.5 oz coffee liqueur (for a mocha twist)

Whiskey alternatives:

• Gentleman Jack (smoother, fewer vanilla notes)
• Evan Williams (cheaper but harsher)

Tools You’ll Need

You probably have these already:

1. Old-fashioned glass: The short, wide shape lets you smell the aromas better than a tall glass.
2. Bar spoon: Any long-handled spoon works for stirring.
3. Vegetable peeler: To make wide orange zest strips. No peeler? Use a knife to carefully slice off the peel.

How to Make a Jack Daniels Margarita

Step 1 | Prepare Your Glass

Run an orange wedge around the rim of your glass. Dip it in coarse sugar if you like sweet edges (we usually skip this to keep it less sugary).

Step 2 | Build the Drink

Add 5 ice cubes to your glass. Pour the Jack Daniel’s over the ice, followed by the amaretto.

Step 3 | Stir Gently

Using your bar spoon, stir clockwise 12 times. Why clockwise? My husband says it’s tradition, but I think it mixes better this way.

Step 4 | Garnish

Hold the orange peel over the glass, shiny side down. Pinch it to spray citrus oils onto the drink’s surface, then drop it in.

Tips for the Perfect Drink

• Chill your glass for 10 minutes in the freezer first – it keeps the drink colder longer.
• Use fresh ice – old freezer ice absorbs food smells (nobody wants pizza-flavored margaritas).
• Stir, don’t shake – shaking makes it too frothy. We want silky-smooth texture.

What Is Jack Daniel’s Good to Mix With?

Through years of kitchen experiments (some successful, some…not), I’ve found these mixers pair best:

1. Amaretto: The nutty almond flavor melts into the whiskey’s vanilla notes – it’s like they were made for each other.
2. Citrus juices: Orange, lemon, or lime brighten the drink without making it sour.
3. Ginger beer: For a spicy kick, skip the amaretto and add ginger beer with a lime wedge.

Avoid grapefruit juice – it clashes with the caramel tones. Pineapple juice works if you add a teaspoon of honey.

Delicious Recipes To Enjoy With Margaritas

A good Jack Daniels Margarita deserves some tasty food alongside it! Over the years, I’ve found certain dishes that pair perfectly with this drink.

My favorite foods to serve with Jack Daniels Margaritas:

1. Spicy nachos: The heat pairs wonderfully with the sweet notes in the drink
2. BBQ wings: The smoky BBQ flavor complements the oak in Jack Daniels
3. Cheese board: Especially with smoked cheeses and dried fruits
4. Honey-roasted nuts: The sweetness echoes the Amaretto notes
5. Pulled pork sliders: The rich meat stands up well to the strong drink
6. Bacon-wrapped dates: Sweet, salty, and perfect with this cocktail

Jack Daniels Margarita Recipe FAQs

1. Can you mix Jack Daniels and tequila?

Yes! Mixing Jack Daniels with tequila creates a bold, smoky margarita. Try half whiskey, half tequila for a unique twist.

2. Can Jack Daniels be refrigerated?

Yes, but it’s not necessary. Jack Daniels stores well at room temperature, but chilling it can give a smoother taste.

3. Can Jack Daniels freeze?

No, Jack Daniels won’t freeze in a normal freezer because of its high alcohol content.

4. Does Jack Daniels go with orange juice?

Yes! The sweet and citrusy flavors blend well, creating a refreshing drink.

5. Does Jack Daniels go with Sprite?

Absolutely! The lemon-lime flavor of Sprite complements the whiskey’s smoothness.

6. Does Jack Daniels make you drunk?

Yes, like any alcohol, drinking too much can make you feel drunk. Always drink responsibly!

7. Is Jack Daniels dark liquor?

Yes, it is a dark whiskey with rich caramel and vanilla flavors.

Continue to Content

Jack Daniels Margarita Recipe

Yield: 1 cocktail

Prep Time: 1 minute

Total Time: 1 minute

Sip on this easy Jack Daniels Margarita recipe in just 1 minute! A smooth, sweet cocktail made with whiskey, amaretto, and citrus aroma.

Print

Ingredients

• Jack Daniels Bourbon: 1.5 oz (45 ml)
• Amaretto: 1.5 oz (45 ml)
• Ice Cubes: 5 standard cubes
• Orange Peel: 1 strip, for garnish

Instructions

Step 1 | Prepare Your Glass

Run an orange wedge around the rim of your glass. Dip it in coarse sugar if you like sweet edges (we usually skip this to keep it less sugary).

Step 2 | Build the Drink

Add 5 ice cubes to your glass. Pour the Jack Daniel's over the ice, followed by the amaretto.

Step 3 | Stir Gently

Using your bar spoon, stir clockwise 12 times. Why clockwise? My husband says it’s tradition, but I think it mixes better this way.

Step 4 | Garnish

Hold the orange peel over the glass, shiny side down. Pinch it to spray citrus oils onto the drink’s surface, then drop it in.

Nutrition Information:

Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 190Total Fat: 0gSaturated Fat: 0gCholesterol: 0mgSodium: 5mgCarbohydrates: 15gFiber: 0gSugar: 14gProtein: 0g

Conclusion

I hope you’ll try this Jack Daniels Margarita Recipe and love it as much as I do! It’s the drink that turned me from a wine-only gal into a whiskey lover. It’s the perfect mix of sweet, strong, and simple. Share your creation with friends, or enjoy it solo on a lazy Saturday.

Don’t forget to tag us on Pinterest with your twist—we’d love to see it! Cheers to good drinks and great moments!